Penalties Details On Couriers and Banks in Non Compliance on Ecommerce taxes in Pakistan

    • Penalties Details On Couriers and Banks in Non Compliance on Ecommerce taxes in Pakistan

    Here are the summary and calculation of penalties on failure to comply on ecommerce taxes withheld in Pakistan.

    Penalties Summary Table with Numerical Examples

    (Base Tax Liability: Rs. 500,000)


    Violation
    Penalty Calculation
    Total Penalty Amount
    Severity
    1. Failure to Withhold Tax Tax Not Paid + 100% Penalty Rs. 500,000 + Rs. 500,000 = Rs. 1,000,000 ⚠️ Very High
    2. Late Payment (30 Days) Default Surcharge = (KIBOR + 3%) × Tax × Days Late <br> (Assume KIBOR=15% → 18% annual) Rs. 500,000 × (18%/365) × 30 = Rs. 7,397 ⚠️ High
    3. Late Filing (10 Days Late) Rs. 10,000 (1st default) + Rs. 1,000/day × 10 days Rs. 10,000 + Rs. 10,000 = Rs. 20,000 ⚠️ High
    4. Hosting Non-Registered Seller Opportunity Cost (Est. 70% revenue loss) + Seizure Risk (Goods Value) Rs. 10,000,000+ (Indirect) 🔴 Catastrophic
    5. Under-Withholding (50% Shortfall) Tax Shortfall + 100% Penalty + Surcharge Rs. 250,000 + Rs. 250,000 + Rs. 3,699 = Rs. 503,699 ⚠️ Very High
    6. Willful Evasion (Prosecution) Fine (Up to Rs. 1,000,000) + Imprisonment (Up to 3 years) Rs. 1,000,000+ + Jail Term 🔴 Catastrophic

    Key Calculations Explained

    Example 1: Failure to Withhold Tax

    • Scenario: Courier ignores Rs. 500,000 tax from a brand.
    • Penalty:
      • Pay the unwithheld tax: Rs. 500,000
      • 100% penalty: Rs. 500,000
      • Total: Rs. 1,000,000 (plus surcharge if paid late).

    Example 2: Late Payment (30 Days)

    • Scenario: Bank withholds Rs. 500,000 but deposits 30 days late.
    • Surcharge Calculation:
      • Annual Rate = KIBOR (15%) + 3% = 18%
      • Daily Rate = 18% ÷ 365 = 0.0493%
      • Surcharge = Rs. 500,000 × 0.0493% × 30 days = Rs. 7,397.

    Example 3: Late Filing (10 Days Late)

    • Scenario: Withholding return filed 10 days after the due date (first default).
    • Penalty:
      • First default: Rs. 10,000
      • Daily fine: Rs. 1,000 × 10 days = Rs. 10,000
      • Total: Rs. 20,000.

    Example 4: Hosting Non-Registered Seller

    • Scenario: Courier clears goods for a seller with no NTN/STRN.
    • Consequences:
      • FBR suspends withholding status → Courier loses 70% of e-commerce revenue (e.g., Rs. 10M/month).
      • Goods seized (e.g., shipment value = Rs. 2M).
      • Blacklisting → Loss of future contracts.
      • No direct "penalty", but indirect costs exceed Rs. 10,000,000.

    Example 5: Under-Withholding (50% Shortfall)

    • Scenario: Bank withholds only Rs. 250,000 (should be Rs. 500,000).
    • Penalty:
      • Tax Shortfall: Rs. 250,000
      • 100% Penalty: Rs. 250,000
      • Surcharge (30-day delay on shortfall): Rs. 250,000 × (18%/365) × 30 = Rs. 3,699
      • Total: Rs. 503,699.

    Example 6: Willful Evasion

    • Scenario: Deliberate non-compliance by a bank officer.
    • Penalty:
      • Fine: Up to Rs. 1,000,000 (discretionary).
      • Jail: Up to 3 years imprisonment.
      • Reputational Damage: Irrecoverable.

    Critical Notes

    1. Compounding Effect: Penalties stack (e.g., late filing + under-withholding + surcharge).
    2. KIBOR Volatility: Surcharge rates change monthly (e.g., KIBOR=20% → 23% annual rate).
    3. Non-Registered Sellers: The biggest risk. Facilitating them triggers operational shutdown (suspension of status).
    4. FBR Discretion: Prosecution fines and imprisonment are case-specific.
    5. Practical Impact: A single Rs. 500,000 tax error can cost over Rs. 1.5 million in penalties.
    Pakistan taxes in Ecommerce

    Conclusion

    • Compliance Cost: Implementing verification systems (NTN/STRN checks) is far cheaper than penalties.
    • Worst Case: Hosting non-registered sellers or willful evasion can bankrupt a business.
    • Action Required:
      • Banks/Couriers: Validate seller NTN/STRN before processing transactions.
      • Automate Systems: Use FBR’s IRIS for real-time tax verification.
      • File On Time: Even 1-day delay triggers Rs. 1,000/day fines.

    Bottom Line: The math is brutal—penalties often exceed 200% of the original tax liability. Proactive compliance is non-negotiable.

    References Details:

    Primary Legal References

    1. Sales Tax Act, 1990


    2. Income Tax Ordinance, 2001


    Key Statutory Regulatory Orders (SROs)

    1. SRO 1125(I)/2021


    2. SRO 1550(I)/2023


    3. SRO 1568(I)/2021

    • Procedure for Registration and Withholding by E-commerce Operators

    FBR Guidelines and Circulars

    1. FBR's Guide on E-commerce Taxation


    2. FBR Circular No. 07 of 2021


    Official References for Penalties

    1. FBR's Penalty Catalogue


    2. FBR's Enforcement Manual


    How to Cite These References

    For academic or professional purposes, you can cite these references as follows:


    1. For Legal Provisions:

      Section 8D of the Sales Tax Act, 1990 (Pakistan)

    2. For SROs:

      Federal Board of Revenue (2021). SRO 1125(I)/2021: Withholding of Sales Tax on E-commerce. Islamabad: Government of Pakistan.

    3. For FBR Guidelines:

      Federal Board of Revenue (2021). Guide on E-commerce Taxation in Pakistan. Islamabad: FBR.

    Please note, if there can be any mistake in the citations and penalty details you can write us back for feedback and correction.

    Previous
    Recent Posts

    What are you looking for?

    Your cart